As more states are cracking down on drinking and driving, some policy makers are moving to incite special license plates for those who have been convicted of Driving Under the Influence (DUI) or similar offenses.
In addition to Ohio, where the practice of issuing “Scarlet Letter” license plates for DUI offenders has a long-standing tradition, several other states have implemented similar measures. Let’s delve deeper into these states and explore the nuances of their approaches:
1. Georgia
- Georgia’s Approach: Georgia’s “Scarlet Letter” plates are less visually conspicuous than Ohio’s red-on-yellow plates. Instead of a distinct color scheme, Georgia opts for subtle identifiers—usually an extra letter or number—in the license plate number. These markings serve as a warning to law enforcement officers, alerting them to the driver’s DUI history.
- Effectiveness and Controversy: While proponents argue that these subtle markers enhance public safety by identifying repeat offenders, critics contend that they stigmatize individuals unfairly. The balance between deterrence and potential harm remains a topic of ongoing debate.
2. Minnesota
- Minnesota’s Unique Markings: Minnesota also requires specific letters and numbers on the license plates of DUI offenders. These markings are not immediately noticeable to the average observer but serve as a discreet signal to law enforcement. Like Georgia, Minnesota aims to strike a balance between public safety and individual rights.
- Balancing Transparency and Privacy: Minnesota’s approach acknowledges the need for transparency while respecting the privacy and dignity of those convicted of DUI. The challenge lies in ensuring that these identifiers do not lead to unintended consequences for offenders.
3. New Hampshire and Beyond
- New Hampshire’s Absence of Scarlet Letters: Unlike Ohio, Georgia, and Minnesota, New Hampshire has not considered implementing “Scarlet Letter” license plates for DUI offenders. However, it’s essential to recognize that practices may evolve over time. States continually evaluate their approaches to combat drunk driving, and public opinion can influence policy decisions.
- Broader Implications: The debate extends beyond specific states. It raises questions about the effectiveness of visible markers, the potential impact on employment prospects, and the delicate balance between accountability and rehabilitation.
Conclusion
Individuals who are required to use these special license plates have to turn their current license plates over to the Department or Bureau of Motor Vehicles within their state, at which time they are given their restricted plates.
These plates are required to be on the offender’s vehicle for the duration of his or her driver’s license suspension regardless of if this suspension was ordered by the court or was considered an administrative suspension.
While the “Scarlet Letter” license plates remain a topic of debate, their existence underscores the ongoing efforts to combat drunk driving across multiple states. As DUI attorneys, we advocate for responsible behavior, legal representation, and road safety awareness.
By understanding the nuances of each state’s approach, we can better navigate the complexities of DUI cases and protect individuals’ rights.
